Icy’s Mafia 2 - Day 3

Shive said:
No because I believe sheriff is inno and I don't want an inno to unnecessarily die (we all know the dangers of tieing thanks to last mafia game, so we should be more wary).

Would be nice if other people that signed up can please participate, it can't just be me vs. Dz
Click to expand...
Might do another ‘purge’ and get rid of a few inactive..
View reply.
 
Shive said:
View attachment 281881
As an traitor, dominic's job is to point the finger at anyone else but the mafia... so I think it's safe to say that these people listed are innocent.
Click to expand...
yes make sense and sure enough sheriff is innocent so kinda not clear in my mind though

still voting slicer cuz he's still sus
View reply.
 
Yuxxa said:
yes make sense and sure enough sheriff is innocent so kinda not clear in my mind though

still voting slicer cuz he's still sus
Click to expand...
why?

wait a min... are you the detective, and if so, did you find out slicer is sus? Ik this is a reach but its odd that u vote him with basically no evidence.
View reply.
 
Shive said:
why?

wait a min... are you the detective, and if so, did you find out slicer is sus? Ik this is a reach but its odd that u vote him with basically no evidence.
Click to expand...
like sher said, the knife part just pointing the "slice-r" name. possibly he's the one of the mafia/traitor (that's just my thought, idk about yall opinion)
View reply.
 
Yuxxa said:
like sher said, the knife part just pointing the "slice-r" name. possibly he's the one of the mafia/traitor (that's just my thought, idk about yall opinion)
Click to expand...
hmm, ok so about that, imo I dont think it makes him sus because in past mafia games and days, icy has written mafia using a variety of weapons like knives, guns, etc. so i dont think its a clue, i personally think thats the way icy wrote it, but I will definitely keep it in the back of my mind.
View reply.
 
Shive said:
wait a min... are you the detective, and if so, did you find out slicer is sus? Ik this is a reach but its odd that u vote him with basically no evidence.
Click to expand...
plus if i was detective as well, ofc i would like to check him for the first time and see what's his role.

for now, i'll just wait the times to see the truth
View reply.
 
Shive said:
No because I believe sheriff is inno and I don't want an inno to unnecessarily die (we all know the dangers of tieing thanks to last mafia game, so we should be more wary).
Click to expand...

Mmmm we only have one tie this whole season so we won’t be able to replicate last season when we did a tie like every day lol
View reply.
 
I haven't been active on here in a day or two even if this thread had a lot of activity, Kind of odd that you guys are swayed towards me. Might seem overly defensive here but I just wanted to cover my takes on a few responses I've been reading here.

Icy_Hatake said:
Might do another ‘purge’ and get rid of a few inactive..
Click to expand...
Interesting, Wouldn't that be quite a few people eliminated then?

Proximity said:
ah yes im late again, its ok ill vote sheriff and I hope he's not actually the sheriff
Click to expand...
Yeah, I'm not too sure who to vote for but I'll probably vote Sheriff because I'm biased and because there are a few hints in the narrative that could lead to Sheriff like with the mentioning of police and stuff.

Yuxxa said:
yes make sense and sure enough sheriff is innocent so kinda not clear in my mind though

still voting slicer cuz he's still sus
Click to expand...
How do you know that Sheriff is innocent and what leaded you to the conclusion that I might be suspicious?

Shive said:
why?

wait a min... are you the detective, and if so, did you find out slicer is sus? Ik this is a reach but its odd that u vote him with basically no evidence.
Click to expand...
Yeah, That's definitely a reach that Yuxxa is going for with how he mentioned just a single possible connection between me and the underlying narrative with that not even connecting towards a specific role. Not really sure what to think about this one.

Shive said:
changing my vote to slicer (I have my reasons:whistling:)
Click to expand...
That's a little odd. Weren't you insistent that it was Eyow a few hours ago?
What led to that changing?
View reply.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Users Who Are Viewing This Thread (Total: 0, Members: 0, Guests: 0)

Back
Top