Icy’s Mafia 2 - Day 3

[Dominicshortbow]

Yes I am
View attachment 281896 View attachment 281896 View attachment 281896 View attachment 281896

nah u cant

View reply.

 

[~~Kxmmy_~~]

nah u cant

Yes I can , irl

View reply.

 

[Shive]

there's 43 people who signed up for this mafia game and we barely getting replies and such so people- can y'all please add your ideas and be active in this mafia game if you can. Thanks.

View reply.

 

[Dominicshortbow]

there's 43 people who signed up for this mafia game and we barely getting replies and such so people- can y'all please add your ideas and be active in this mafia game if you can. Thanks.

lets start just tagging all of them!

View reply.

 

[Dz81]

It is.

He is on the sus list for sure, we could vote him out next if we aren’t sure who to vote.

So I was looking back on previous mafia days and doing some thinking and I noticed that day 2 mentioned that lake, the lake was kind of a major significant part in that day. Lakes have animals such as ducks and frogs
-Softwareslicer: frog
-Pufflin, duck: duck

Just putting ideas out there

That’s actually a really good observation, me & Luna were thinking the lake had something to do with liking the color blue, but those ideas could also work

View reply.

 

[Dz81]

Y'all I don't think we should be voting for sheriff. In the last day, dominic and foz were gunning for sheriff, trying to make people vote for him, and now that we know that foz AND dominic are TRAITORS, we really shouldn't be trusting their word. They are pointing the finger at sheriff to save the mafia azz. Look:
View attachment 281878
there are more posts in the last thread where dominic was urging everyone to vote for sheriff which was his downfall and made him sus.View attachment 281879

View attachment 281881
As an traitor, dominic's job is to point the finger at anyone else but the mafia... so I think it's safe to say that these people listed are innocent.

He could be using some reverse psychology tricks on us. When I was traitor I did this too to try to defend Ruby. Like during the ties when I wanted to try and tie the votes between Ruby & Maegan and Ruby & Trenz. We don’t really have much to loose here if we vote out Sheriff unless he’s the joker (which I doubt). I think Dom & faz could just be pulling some reverse psychology to make us think Sheriff’s inno

View reply.

 

[Shive]

I think Dom & faz could just be pulling some reverse psychology to make us think Sheriff’s inno

But dominic was a little too adament about voting sheriff, he over emphasized voting sheriff and calling sheriff "sus" to the point where we all got sus of him and he ended up getting voted out. That's mainly my reasoning for not wanting to vote out sheriff.

View reply.

 

[Dz81]

He could be using some reverse psychology tricks on us. When I was traitor I did this too to try to defend Ruby. Like during the ties when I wanted to try and tie the votes between Ruby & Maegan and Ruby & Trenz. We don’t really have much to loose here if we vote out Sheriff unless he’s the joker (which I doubt). I think Dom & faz could just be pulling some reverse psychology to make us think Sheriff’s inno

Last time I pretended like I didn’t care Ruby was about to get voted out making it look like I she was inno bc I wasn’t taking any action to defend her. Dom & Faz could be doing the same things. Same works the other way around, like last time I tried pretending like I was defending Gab to take the attention off Ruby when Gab was inno all along. We just have to be careful not to fall for some things.

View reply.

 

[Dz81]

But dominic was a little too adament about voting sheriff, he over emphasized voting sheriff and calling sheriff "sus" to the point where we all got sus of him and he ended up getting voted out. That's mainly my reasoning for not wanting to vote out sheriff.

Well I was kind of like that with Ruby too

Hello? Why is Ruby still alive? I thought they both got voted out.

(No offense or anything at all ruby lol)

Ok wait no this is twice in a row now why isn’t Ruby D Y I N G ? ?

Who broke the tie last round this time?

Maybe Sher is inno, maybe he isn’t, but it’s still worth a shot to try and eliminate him.

View reply.

 

[Shive]

I also think it is worth pointing out that the people the mafia are killing out people who aren't really active... makes me wonder if they are just killing out their friends or something

View reply.

 

[Dz81]

I also think it is worth pointing out that the people the mafia are killing out people who aren't really active... makes me wonder if they are just killing out their friends or something

I also noticed that too. Something else I noticed was that Ruby & Zabby (the 2 mafias last round) were both killed in Day 1 & 2 (probably by the same mafia) so one of the mafias this round most likely played last mafia. Although this does apply to like 20 people, it could help when we're down to like the final 10 or so when there are fewer players remaining.

View reply.

 

[Shive]

Well I was kind of like that with Ruby too






Maybe Sher is inno, maybe he isn’t, but it’s still worth a shot to try and eliminate him.

No shade to you guys but y'all had a whole a** plan last mafia game that included literally everyone where you and the other traitors would tell each other and the other "innos" exactly what to say: you could afford to look innocent and say certain stuff (using the reverse psycology) because you had so many other people to fall back on; here it is different, dom and foz can't rlly pull what u guys pull

View reply.

 

[Dz81]

No shade to you guys but y'all had a whole a** plan last mafia game that included literally everyone where you and the other traitors would tell each other and the other "innos" exactly what to say: you could afford to look innocent and say certain stuff (using the reverse psycology) because you had so many other people to fall back on; here it is different, dom and foz can't rlly pull what u guys pull

Trueeeeeeeeee but like Dom & Faz could still attempt to make it seem like certain people (ex sheriff) are innos when they're actually something else. They could purposely try to not give much attention to that person making us think that those people are inno when they actually aren't yk?

View reply.

 

[Shive]

Trueeeeeeeeee but like Dom & Faz could still attempt to make it seem like certain people (ex sheriff) are innos when they're actually something else. They could purposely try to not give much attention to that person making us think that those people are inno when they actually aren't yk?

I disagree because people were already suspicious of sheriff before, and dominic and foz used that to their advantage to play up the suspicion and rile up the innos to vote sheriff out to give the mafia more days/time to kill- just like what a traitor would do. But only, it backfired against dominic cuz he was going overboard, and everyone voted against him. So I think sheriff is rlly inno.

Personally, I think it's eyow :v

View reply.

 

[Dz81]

I disagree because people were already suspicious of sheriff before, and dominic and foz used that to their advantage to play up the suspicion and rile up the innos to vote sheriff out to give the mafia more days/time to kill- just like what a traitor would do. But only, it backfired against dominic cuz he was going overboard, and everyone voted against him.

Mmmm I see, but it looks like Sheriff is probably getting booted anyways so we'll just have to see how it goes
Edit: Nvm I just realized how few votes there are so there's a chance Sheriff might live

Personally, I think it's eyow :v

I also think that one of the mafias could be eyow mostly bc of the clue with how Zabby killed Eyow first last round & this round Eyow killed Zabby first this round for revenge maybe?

View reply.

 

[Shive]

Mmmm I see, but it looks like Sheriff is probably getting booted anyways so we'll just have to see how it goes


I also think that one of the mafias could be eyow mostly bc of the clue with how Zabby killed Eyow first last round & this round Eyow killed Zabby first this round for revenge maybe?

yea that was what i was thinking, and on the first day, there was mention of tall buildings, and luna said that maybe that can possibly point to a builder.

I vote eyow.

View reply.

 

[Dz81]

yea that was what i was thinking, and on the first day, there was mention of tall buildings, and luna said that maybe that can possibly point to a builder.

I vote eyow.

I'm going to vote Sheriff this round. Eyow is sus for sure & I'll probably vote him sometime in a future day & there are 3 mafias after all so one could be Eyow & one could be Sheriff.

View reply.

 

[Dz81]

The townspeople voted out Dominic and sent him to death. He didn’t complain nor yell at how wrong everyone was, instead just smiled as he was taken away as he had for the most part fulfilled his role.

Another thing I noticed was that in Icy's story, it mentioned that Dom had fulfilled his role for the most part so maybe Dom has successfully defended/protected a mafia from being eliminated? Maybe we could go back through the previous days & create a list of people who Dom has tried defending/accusing and seeing if any of the clues we have gathered so far pertains to them?

View reply.

 

[Dz81]

Another thing I noticed was that in Icy's story, it mentioned that Dom had fulfilled his role for the most part so maybe Dom has successfully defended/protected a mafia from being eliminated? Maybe we could go back through the previous days & create a list of people who Dom has tried defending/accusing and seeing if any of the clues we have gathered so far pertains to them?

Ok going back through the first 2 days I’ve notice that Dom has tried defending Eyow in a previous day & Faz kind of hinted towards a mafia potentially being Eyow.

Yeah, the only problem is that not much clues lead to eyow!

It’s all fun and games until you read “icy’s mafia 2, day 3/finale”

I feel like Eyow is a mafia, but Sheriff too but it’s kind of 50/50 with Sheriff. Are you guys up for maybe making a tie vote between Eyow & Sheriff?

View reply.

 

[Shive]

Ok going back through the first 2 days I’ve notice that Dom has tried defending Eyow in a previous day & Faz kind of hinted towards a mafia potentially being Eyow.

I feel like Eyow is a mafia, but Sheriff too but it’s kind of 50/50 with Sheriff. Are you guys up for maybe making a tie vote between Eyow & Sheriff?

No because I believe sheriff is inno and I don't want an inno to unnecessarily die (we all know the dangers of tieing thanks to last mafia game, so we should be more wary).

Would be nice if other people that signed up can please participate, it can't just be me vs. Dz

View reply.