Solving a Mystery

[Bearrel]

• John and Mary were lying on the floor.
• Mary was dead.
• Their was a puddle of water and broken glass on the floor.

What happened, and who were John and Mary?

You may ask only 1 yes or no question.

 

[EVILBANANA12345]

• John and Mary were lying on the floor.
• Mary was dead.
• Their was a puddle of water and broken glass on the floor.

What happened, and who were John and Mary?

You may ask only 1 yes or no question.

They are fish

View reply.

 

[Ripcord]

They were fish, and their bowl fell and they died.

View reply.

 

[EVILBANANA12345]

They were fish, and their bowl fell and they died.

Beat u to it

View reply.

 

[Ripcord]

Beat u to it

You didn't say what happened. I've won so like..yeah bow down please

View reply.

 

[EVILBANANA12345]

You didn't say what happened. I've won so like..yeah bow down please

I have heard the joke before
Another one of the clues was a window was open and a light brease was coming through

View reply.

 

[Bearrel]

u guys are half right...

View reply.

 

[Ripcord]

u guys are half right...

Were they inside a glass which broke XD

View reply.

 

[Bearrel]

Another one of the clues was a window was open and a light brease was coming through

This is not the exact riddle. It is a little different

View reply.

 

[Bearrel]

Were they inside a glass which broke XD

Hint: Mary was, but what about John? I never said he died...

View reply.

 

[Ripcord]

Hint: Mary was, but what about John? I never said he died...

OHHH so John got flushed in the toilet and Mary fell on the seat and died and the water glass broke because someone farted? Uh...

View reply.

 

[Visualz]

Was John a bird who broke the window to eat Mary?

View reply.

 

[lucas1901]

John was sleeping

View reply.

 

[windexx]

The fishbowl broke, and John fell in the puddle of water. Mary, however, died.

View reply.

 

[EVILBANANA12345]

John dropped the fish bowl and Mary was the fish @BearlordTheGr8

View reply.

 

[Bearrel]

John dropped the fish bowl and Mary was the fish @BearlordTheGr8

Really close! But who is John???

View reply.

 

[EVILBANANA12345]

Really close! But who is John???

A cat

View reply.

 

[Bearrel]

Was John a bird who broke the window to eat Mary?

You are on the right track, but John is not a bird

View reply.

 

[Bearrel]

A cat

YES!!! Congrats! You solved the mystery!!!

View reply.

 

[Bearrel]

A new mystery coming soon, and this one will be intense...

View reply.