My ratings:
Abandoned Hotel - 4/10
To be honest it makes me kind of claustrophobic. It's too small and the sheriff and innocents have hard times surviving/hunting down the murderer. There's also no op hiding spots that aren't too obvious, and it's pretty hard to run away from the murderer in such a small area.
Aquarium B - 5/10
This map is the opposite of Abandoned Hotel. It's large enough for the sheriff and innocents to easily survive. However, I always get lost in the maze and end up either running into the murderer or circling back to the place I spawned in the maze. The maze makes the murderer's job of killing people harder, tbh. There are a lot of hiding places that you can only access through one way.
Mansion - 5/10
Another average/big area to run around. There aren't too many op hiding spots for me to hide in without the murderer knowing (unless they are new to the server), and the spots that I hide in are easily accessible to anyone.
Forest - 8/10
A really big area to run around in. The rain and mist makes the job a little bit easier for the murderer. There are a few hiding spots that aren't obvious, such as the trees next to the house and tents. They serve as a look-out tower for me to look out for the murderer and the sheriff.
Rugrats - 6/10
Another big area that is easy for all players to play on. There's a maze underneath the map that can be challenging to the murderer when it comes to hunting people down, and there are a few op spots too. The tree serves as a lookout tower, but part of the view is obscured by the leaves, and you have to lookout for the murderer on the furtherest leaves and risk the murderer climbing up the tree while doing so. If you hide behind part of the stone fence in front of the garage, it is pretty hard to escape the murderer if they notice you hiding there.
Wild West - 6/10
An average sized area. It's hard to win as murderer there though, because of the high places you have to parkour to and the risk of being shot by the sheriff whilst parkouring.
School N - 6/10
Only played on it once. It's okay, reminds me of the old Hotel map with the spiral staircase that you can fall down. There are one or two places that are pretty op to hide in.
Abandoned School - 6/10
A bit cluttered, and kind of hard to win as the murderer because of the abundance of hiding spots. Hard to run without running into blocks on the ground floor.
Castle - 7/10
Open - can play as an advantage towards the murderer and sheriff. A few high hiding spots that requires parkour to reach. Has an underground cave that has a few hiding places.
Haunted Mansion - 7/10
Big, has hiding spots that once hidden you can't escape - disadvantage to the murderer. Can parkour on the lamps to reach other places like the light decorations and barriers.
Clown - 9/10
My favourite map. Is easy to win as sheriff, a bit harder to win as murderer. You can parkour on the haunted house, and it serves as a great look out tower. A few op hiding spots on the ferris wheel, in the circus tent, and in the haunted house.
Clue - 7/10
A few op hiding spots. A bit small, but not as small as Abandoned Hotel. Easy to win as murderer or sheriff.